Showing posts with label chinese BBQ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chinese BBQ. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

CONCLUSION

"Focus on the journey, not the destination. Joy is found not in finishing an activity but in doing it." - Greg Anderson

The climax of Chopstick Chowdown Challenge was more of an anti-climax. We turned up ready for the last restaurant only to realise we had already been to the last restaurant. So we went back for a third helping of chilli fish.

Now when I walk back along Victoria St, I see new restaurants have sprung up. Others have disappeared. But this is the kaleidoscopic nature of this vibrant strip which we have had the pleasure to thoroughly sample.

It only took about 16 months but we did it! We completed the challenge of eating at every Asian restaurant on Victoria St between Church and Hoddle Streets. And what an epic experience it was. We delighted our palates, we tried foods we never thought we'd try, we made some wonderful discoveries. My mouth waters again as I go through the blog and am reminded of our culinary experiences. It has also been a portrait of friendships (some transient, some enduring), social experiences and the banter that comes with a group of people sharing a meal. People may come and go but true friendships and good food remain!

However, for those who like their conclusions less philosophical and more mathematical, here are the stats.

THE STATISTICS


Participants: 29
Restaurants: 36
Dishes eaten: 196
Number of bowls of pho consumed: 19

BEST RESTAURANT

I performed two types of statistical analysis on the ratings I had from participants for each restaurants:
i) the mean of the top 3 rated dishes
ii) the mean of all the dishes minus the top and bottom ranked.

In both cases, the top ranking resturant came out the same. Drumroll please...

#1 YU XIANG LAPOPO


It seems we just couldn't get enough of that chilli fish. But Victoria St is known for its Vietnamese restaraunts, right? The runner up (or best Vietnamese restaurant) according to the first analysis was...

#2 (i) THANH HA

And according to the second analysis

#2 (ii) THANH THANH

The bronze medal winner was the same...

#3 QUAN 88

Other restaurants making up the top 10 were...

Ying Thai
Vinh Vinh
Tom Toon Noodle House
Binh Minh
Oriental Spirit
Saigon Rose
Thy Thy


Although I have allocated winners, it is only according to the results of this little experiment where ranking were often very close and scores affected by variables (such as who attended, how generous they were with their ratings, personal tastes, experiences on the day, etc). At the end of the day it is a matter of personal preference but hopefully I have managed to capture a sample of the best picks on Victoria St.

BEST DISHES

Overall the dishes which scored the highest (the mean participant rating on the night) over the course of the challenge were:

#1 Vietnamese Salad - Vi'em Cafe (9.1/10)
#2 Pad Kee Mao - Tom Toon Noodle House (9/10)
Chilli Fish Bowl - YuXiang Lapopo (9/10)
Coconut Beef - Quan 88 (9/10)
#3 Peking Duck - Binh Minh (8.9/10)


At the start of this challenge I promised to find you the best pho and a list of other dishes. Here are the results.

Best Pho
#1 Thy Thy
#2 Thanh Ma

Best Ricepaper Rolls

# 1 Tran Tran
#2 Vinh Vinh

Best Spring Rolls

#1 Binh Minh
#1 Thanh Ha
(Special mention for Quan 88's duck spring roll special)

Best Peking Duck
#1 Binh Minh
#2 Pacific BBQ House

Best Green Curry
Tom Toon

Best Satay Skewers
Oriental Spirit

Personally there are some dishes that stand out in my mind, that I continued thinking about for days after. So here are my special mentions:
  • Soft shell crab - Thanh Thanh
  • Peking duck - Pacific BBQ House
  • BBQ pork with Chinese broccoli - I Spicy
  • Whole fish with spicy sour sauce - Ying Thai
  • Szechaun mud crab - Xiao Ting Box
  • Chilli fish - YuXiang Lapopo

Thanks again everyone who participated, especially Steph (for saying "let's do this" and putting in the most ChChCh appearances) and Craig (for being our most enthusiastic and consistent participant once recruited from England).

There is a gap on Sunday nights now - a time when you want to savour the last moments of the weekend and not think about the impending working week. Maybe we can begin a new challenge...the mission to find the best Indian food in Melbourne...Curry Chowdown Challenge?!?

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

#10 Minh Tan II (190-192 Victoria St)

Attendees: Beata, Penny, Andrew Be, Craig, Mike

Chopstick Chowdown Challenge took a step towards international fame with a couple of English visitors joining us. The venue – Minh Thanh 2 (does this mean there is a Minh Than 1 to be looking forward to?) which is described outside as Vietnamese Chinese BBQ. The restaurant spreads over 2 street numbers, the strung up roast ducks and acccompanying duck cutting master take up most of the wide front window. A narrow entrance opens out into a spacious area, characterised by the yellow outside and cream inside. This is contrasted by the blue light panels on one wall which give it a slight nightclub feel.

By the door there is a display cabinet where you can purchase fluffy pork buns and various desserts. Andrew is eyeing these off. To my right is the mandatory plasma screen. Here we have a twist – the plasma screen advertises menu items with accompanying photos, including some of the more unique items such as chicken feet and peking duck (which according to the photo is a whole duck, head inclusive).

I can see the duck cutting master at work and am about to draw everyone’s attention to his artistry when he picks up a duck and using a giant cleaver, with one rapid motion slices it through the middle letting liquid and innards flow out. I only have a moment to recover as the waiter stands over me waiting for the order.

Andrew and I comment on the recurring ornaments at Asian restaurants (like the gold waving cat that is always pointed at the door to greet customers). We debate the meaning of an ornament which has one large apple and lots of little ones. There is a feeling of clutter, yet our table seems expectionally spacious.

Our English friends are looking a little pink from the day's excursion and Penny comments on her own inability to tan. "That's because we work in IT," jests Andrew.

The waiting staff stand at attention. They run a tight ship here. I don’t know if I’m speaking loudly or if they have special mind-reading abilities but as soon as I complain about the lack of condiments for my dumplings, a bottle of vinegar lands under my nose. The manager is multi-tasking, a portable phone on one ear, while barking instructions at staff and noticing everyone who enters the restaurant. He’s all over it.

Being a massive fan of dumplings I have done the rounds of dumpling restaurants (I will give Hutong Dumpling a free plug here for their excellent xiao long bao and chilli wontons). The dumplings here are more like dim sims but still quite tasty.

Number 27 is another soup of Penny's 'favourite' consistency - 'gelatinous'. It has a distinctive fishy flavour which I will attribute to the shark fin. It is not to everyone's tastes but Mike is happy to finish off the leftovers.

Again we can't stay away from the peking duck and it is excellent. The deep-fried soft shell prawns come out looking great but there is only one word to describe them...'salty'! But there is the joy of eating prawns whole and while some baulk at munching down on the head, I contend that it is the best bit. To ensure everyone is sufficiently fed, we order a pork and eggplant hotpot, which was surprising spicy, tasty and has a thick curry consistency.

Extra points go to Minh Thanh 2 for the complimentary duck salad that we try to send back. However, we shouldn't have questioned the ability of this disciplined waiter army to get our order correct, as we are politely informed it comes with the peking duck.

Our English friends give it the thumbs up and thank us for showing them a restaurant they wouldn’t have got to themselves. If you don't trust their word, then maybe the queue of people waiting for tables speaks for the quality of the food here.




Ratings
Rice paper rolls 7.8/10
Peking pork dumplings 7.6/10
#27 (sweet corn and sharkfin soup) 6.4/10
Special (deepfried soft shell prawns) 6.4/10
Peking duck 8.2/10

Thursday, November 26, 2009

#7 BBQ Seafood House (5/240 Victoria St)

Attendees: Beata, Steph, Mark R, Penny, Andrew

Am I in the twilight zone or is this place a replica of Pacific BBQ House four doors down? “Only someone who has eaten at every restaurant would make a comment like that,” says Mark in his first week of Chopstick Chowdown Challenge. The strung-up ducks in the front window are there, as is the wall covered in coloured papers with specials. But here we don’t have to wait for a table.

Even the font on the menu looks the same. I do a double take – is it the same menu? However a count down to 27 yields a different item. This week it is vegetarian corn soup, which we begin with, dividing out a small bowl between the five of us in spirit of communal eating. It immediately makes me think of Japan and the addiction that grew there with hot corn soup in a can out of a vending machine. Delicious in a snow storm in Kyoto but is unlikely to ever get a 10 out 10 in Melbourne restaurant.

Next are the plump spring rolls. I take a quick survey of the filling to notice shredded carrot, celery, cabbage and shitake mushroom amongst other ingredients. There is also the bonus of two sweet dipping sauces.

The tea tastes different and Steph suggest a hint of liquorice root. We end up working our way through quite a few pots of it.

Peking duck is becoming our backup staple at Chinese BBQ restaurants and those of us who participated in the Pacific BBQ House have problems shaking the memories of that divine peking duck. My first piece is a little thin on and a bit dry. Penny complains about her pancake falling apart, fatty duck and the lack of hoisin sauce by the time she has finished eating her spring roll with chopsticks. Still there is something about the combination of flavours and textures in peking duck that has me tasting it long after we leave the restaurant.

From the specials board we choose the deep fried oysters with special sauce and sautéed scallops with garlic stem. I love natural oysters and I’ve had Chinese fried oysters at yum cha before that left disillusioned at how the majestic oyster can be ruined. However at Seafood BBQ House the deep fried oysters are a pleasant surprise. Very tender (some suggesting they taste more like scallops than oysters) they had a mild flavour of the sea inside a perfectly fried shell with a touch of gently sweet sauce. Plus at $19 a dozen, a bargain. So good in fact that all five of us did ‘scissors, paper, rock’ over who got the last two.

The scallops come amongst a pile of green stalks that none of us had had before. The garlic stem was like a cross between spring onion and the stalks of Chinese broccoli. A subtle taste of garlic plus a sprinkling of carrot, mushroom and baby sweet corn in the dish. The scallops were perfectly cooked with a touch of sweetness.

We supplement all this with fried rice, which comes with unexpected pile of prawns on top (prawns, not shrimp) and has a great smoky flavour to it. I suppose it should in a BBQ restaurant... Though I find myself looking around for soy sauce and am suddenly struck the complete lack of condiments on the table.

By the time we have finished the restaurant is full. Maybe people are later eaters at BBQ Seafood House. The similarities with Pacific BBQ House are inescapable however lack of divine peking duck aside, I found BBQ Seafood House more even across the board and felt sated. Penny was just happy that nothing was gelatinous.

Ratings
Spring rolls 7.4/10
#27 (vegetarian corn soup) 7/10
Peking duck 7.2/10
Special (deep fried oyster with special sauce) 8.6/10
Special (sautéed scallops with garlic stem) 7/10

Average cost per person: $20

Sunday, November 8, 2009

#5 Pacific BBQ Seafood House (8/240 Victoria Street)



Attendees: Beata, Emma, Penny, Andrew

For the first time in the Chopstick Chowdown Challenge there is no room in the inn. Twenty minutes is given as the approximated time and we decide to wait. This place is obviously popular so the food must be good. Pacific BBQ Seafood House is one of those places where the front window is a graveyard for BBQ ducks and pork strung up on hooks. Tantalising. As we loiter out the front we can watch the chef with a cleaver chopping up whole ducks at such as speed that we worry about his fingertips.

People are crowded just inside in the doorway, waiting for both table and take-away food. Andrew goes inside to check on our table and is convinced a family has swooped in on our table while his back was turned. The waiter tries to move them but they are refusing. It’s a dog eat dog world when it comes to getting tables at Pacific House.

Never fear, within two minutes there is a table for us. When I say a table, I mean part of a table because everything is jammed-packed in here but it adds to the communal eating atmosphere.

I am dazzled by the fluoro signs covering the walls like a grand collection of flags. On these flags in black marker are both Chinese and English characters announcing different dishes.

As soon as we sit down small bowls of soup are placed before us. Excellent…we have food before we even have a menu! Getting a menu (or the waiting staff’s attention) is a little more difficult.

In the meantime I watch the folks around us, the vast majority of whom are of Asian descent. As a large bowl of saucy BBQed squares (pork? tofu?) lands on the table beside us, a granny attacks it with gusto, making swift movements with her chopsticks. She can’t get the garnish off quickly enough, lest it contaminated the food (assumedly).

There are no dumplings on the menu so we substitute spring rolls. They are crispy and plump and come with bright red dipping sauce. No complaints there. Number 27 (as a count down the menu ascertains) is vegetarian san choi bow. It has a pleasant BBQ flavour to it but as Penny says “it is missing something.” “Meat?” suggests Andrew. Alas there is no bacon in the steamed rice either.

As the girl next to me says, the Peking duck is “divine”. Succulent slivers of duck and spring onion in thin floury pancakes with a tangy hoisin sauce. Top stuff!

Off the wall we choose king prawn with king oyster mushrooms. Although the prawns are juicy, the gelatinous sauce lacks flavour and the wafer thin slices of mushroom may as well be tofu. Chinese broccoli with oyster sauce at $16 a serving is outrageous, especially as it is hard and stalky and the oyster sauce had slid off into wateriness.

I think this is one of those restaurants where you need to point to the table next to you and say “we’ll have one of those” because whatever the regulars were ordering looked the best. Or just stick to anything barbequed (like the delicious duck that beckons from the front window) as the restaurant’s name suggests.


Ratings
Spring rolls 7.6/10
Chinese broccoli with oyster sauce 5.1/10
# 27 (vegetarian san choi bow) 7.1/10
Daily special (King prawns with king oyster mushrooms) 6.3/10
Peking duck 8.8/10

Cost per person $25